This week on Property Matters, Gareth Wax and Hamish McLay will be joined by Tiffany Fairbrother as we look at the growing debate around housing standards after comments from Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham calling for tougher action against landlords who repeatedly provide poor housing conditions.
Interestingly, the timing of the discussion feels particularly relevant. Only a few weeks ago on Property Matters we were already discussing rogue landlords operating within parts of the private rented sector, so Burnham’s comments have arrived at a moment when the condition of housing is already very much on people’s minds.
Concerns around damp, mould, disrepair and neglected rental homes have been building for years. Yet the language now being used feels noticeably stronger than before.
The suggestion of a “three strikes” style approach has opened up a much wider conversation about where the balance should sit between enforcement, responsibility and maintaining enough confidence inside the rental market itself.
Most people would probably agree that genuinely poor housing conditions need dealing with properly. Nobody wants to see tenants left living in unsafe or unhealthy homes, particularly where landlords repeatedly ignore warnings or fail to carry out basic work.
At the same time, there is also a growing sense of nervousness across parts of the private rented sector.
Over the last couple of years landlords have faced rising borrowing costs, increasing compliance requirements, EPC uncertainty, taxation changes and now the continuing rollout of the Renters’ Rights Act.
For some landlords, particularly smaller landlords with one or two properties, the pressure is starting to feel relentless.
That does not excuse poor standards. Yet it does create an important distinction between criminal neglect and landlords who may simply be financially stretched or struggling with rising maintenance costs.
One wonders whether that distinction sometimes risks being lost once political conversations become sharper.
There is also the wider question of supply.
If stronger enforcement powers are introduced at the same time as more landlords leave the sector altogether, it could place even more pressure on an already strained rental market. In many areas across the country, demand for rented accommodation is already far exceeding supply.
It would be interesting to know whether tougher enforcement alone can solve housing quality problems without also addressing the growing shortage of available homes.
Another part of the conversation rarely discussed openly is whether local authorities themselves are fully equipped for the role being proposed.
Housing enforcement teams are already under pressure in many councils. Staffing, funding and experience levels vary enormously from one authority to another.
That raises questions about consistency and fairness.
Two landlords operating in different council areas may find themselves facing very different levels of scrutiny or intervention depending on local resources and political priorities.
There is also a wider shift taking place quietly in the background.
As regulation becomes heavier and compliance costs continue to rise, many smaller landlords appear to be stepping away from the sector entirely. In their place, larger operators and institutional investors are gradually becoming more dominant within parts of the rental market.
As always with Property Matters, this is unlikely to become a simple landlords versus tenants discussion. Real life is usually more complicated than that.
The challenge is finding a system that protects people properly without creating even bigger pressures elsewhere inside an already stretched housing market.
This Tuesday at 1pm, Gareth Wax will once again be in the chair as we take a calmer look at one of the most politically charged property discussions currently developing across the country.
Never miss an episode of Spilling the Proper-Tea again, subscribe to our YouTube Channel to catch or watch live:
https://www.youtube.com/@SpillingTheProper-Tea
For content enquiries:
For podcast/media info: